Gift Aid compliance

Are your charity’s claims and controls robust enough?

Gift Aid remains an important source of additional income for UK charities. But it is more than an administrative reclaim. Charities need to be satisfied that donations qualify, declarations are valid, and claims are supported by appropriate records. 

The question for trustees and finance teams is simple: would your Gift Aid claims and supporting records stand up to scrutiny?

Our blog explores the questions charities should ask when considering Gift Aid compliance, in addition to a Gift Aid health checklist at the end of this article. 

Why review Gift Aid now? 

For many charities, Gift Aid is a long-established process. That familiarity can create its own risks. 

Donation methods may have changed, new fundraising platforms may have been introduced and membership or supporter benefits may have evolved, while the process for preparing the Gift Aid claim has remained largely unchanged. 

Changes to charity tax rules from April 2026 provide a further prompt for charities to consider their wider tax compliance arrangements. 

A robust Gift Aid process should demonstrate that: 

  • donations included in claims qualify,
  • valid Gift Aid declarations are held,
  • donor benefits have been considered, 
  • claims are complete and accurate, and 
  • there is appropriate review before submission to HMRC. 

Does the payment qualify for Gift Aid? 

Not every payment received from a supporter is necessarily a donation. 

Particular care may be needed where payments relate to: 

  • membership subscriptions,
  • fundraising events or charity auctions,
  • admission to property or events,
  • sponsorship arrangements,
  • purchases of goods, or 
  • arrangements where the donor, or somebody connected to them, receives a benefit. 

The description applied to a payment does not determine its Gift Aid treatment. Charities need to consider the substance of the arrangement and whether the conditions for Gift Aid are met. 

Are your Gift Aid declarations valid?

A valid Gift Aid declaration is fundamental to a claim. 

Declarations can be made in writing, verbally or electronically and can cover future donations. Charities nevertheless need processes to ensure the required information is obtained and retained, and that cancellations or changes notified by donors are reflected in subsequent claims. 

It is therefore worth periodically reviewing older declarations and checking that donor records remain sufficiently complete to support the amounts being claimed. 

Has the donor received anything in return?

Gift Aid can become more complicated where a donor receives a benefit as a result of their donation. 

HMRC sets limits on the value of benefits that can be provided while a donation remains eligible for Gift Aid. This may be particularly relevant to membership schemes, fundraising events, donor rewards and access to facilities. 

Charities should understand what supporters receive in return for payments and consider whether this affects Gift Aid eligibility. 

What about membership subscriptions?

Subscriptions may qualify for Gift Aid in some circumstances, depending on the benefits provided to members. A charity should not assume that subscriptions continue to qualify simply because Gift Aid has historically been claimed on them. 

If the membership package has changed, perhaps through new events, services, discounts or access to facilities, the Gift Aid treatment should be reconsidered. 

The key question is not just “what does our membership agreement say?” but “what does a member actually receive?” 

Does your process reflect how people donate today?

Increasingly, charities receive income through websites, fundraising platforms, contactless terminals, social media campaigns and other digital channels. That can make the Gift Aid audit trail more complex. 

Where third-party platforms are used, charities should understand: 

  • how Gift Aid declarations are obtained,
  • what donor information is passed to the charity, 
  • what supporting records are retained,
  • how refunds or cancelled donations are dealt with, and 
  • whether amounts claimed can be reconciled back to individual donations. 

A charity should be able to trace amounts included in its Gift Aid claim back to the underlying donation and appropriate supporting evidence.

Could you be missing out on GASDS?

Reviewing Gift Aid is not only about identifying potential overclaims. It can also highlight income the charity may be entitled to but is not currently claiming. 

The Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme (GASDS) allows eligible charities to claim a top-up on certain cash and contactless donations of £30 or less without obtaining a Gift Aid declaration from the individual donor. 

An eligible charity can normally claim on up to £8,000 of qualifying small donations in a tax year, potentially generating an additional £2,000. 

This can be valuable for charities receiving donations through bucket collections, community fundraising, events and contactless giving. Specific eligibility and record-keeping requirements apply, so charities should consider whether they qualify and whether the scheme is being used appropriately. 

A Gift Aid health check 

Trustees and finance teams can start their review by asking eight straightforward questions: 

  1. Do we hold valid Gift Aid declarations? Can we readily produce the declarations supporting our claims?
  2. Can we link donations to the relevant donors? Is there a clear audit trail between the amount received and the declaration supporting it?
  3. Are all payments included in the claim genuinely donations? Have we considered payments relating to events, goods, services and other fundraising activities separately?
  4. Has the donor received anything in return? If so, have we considered the donor benefit rules?
  5. Have we reviewed our membership arrangements? If Gift Aid is claimed on subscriptions, do the benefits currently provided support that treatment?
  6. Are digital donations adequately supported? Can amounts received through fundraising platforms and other digital channels be traced to appropriate records and declarations?
  7. Do our claims reconcile? Can the return be reconciled to the charity’s donor, fundraising and accounting records, with differences investigated?
  8. Who reviews the claim? Is there appropriate review, independent from the preparer where practicable, before the claim is submitted to HMRC?

The extent of that review should be proportionate to the charity. What matters is that the charity can demonstrate that claims have been appropriately prepared, checked and supported. 

What should charities do now? 

Gift Aid can represent a valuable source of additional income, but it should not be treated simply as a routine administrative process. 

Trustees and finance teams should periodically step back and consider whether their Gift Aid arrangements remain appropriate, particularly where fundraising methods, membership schemes or systems have changed. 

A short health check can identify potential errors, improve the audit trail and highlight opportunities where legitimate Gift Aid or GASDS income may currently be missed. 

Ultimately, the question for trustees should go beyond “Are our Gift Aid claims compliant?”

How can Price Bailey help?

Price Bailey has extensive experience with the Charity and Not for Profit sector. If you have any questions regarding Gift Aid you can contact us using the form below.

We always recommend that you seek advice from a suitably qualified adviser before taking any action. The information on this page is intended as a general guide only. While we work to keep our content accurate and up to date, we cannot guarantee that it reflects the position at the time you are reading it. No responsibility for loss occasioned by any person acting or refraining from action as a result of this material can be accepted by the authors or the firm. For more information on our editorial process, click here.

Sign up to receive exclusive business insights

Join our community of industry leaders and receive exclusive reports, early event access, and expert advice to stay ahead – all delivered straight to your inbox.

Sign up

Have a question about this post? Ask our team...

We can help

Contact us today to find out more about how we can help you

Top