Could a higher employer NI threshold for 21 to 24 year olds help retail and hospitality?
Alan Milburn’s review into youth unemployment has brought National Insurance back into the spotlight. One of his recommendations is to cut the cost of hiring 21 to 24 year olds, starting with the retail and hospitality sectors. The change would apply to employer NI, the contribution the business pays on top of wages, not the National Insurance taken from an employee’s pay.
The cost of employing younger staff has climbed year after year. The National Living Wage has risen by around 11 percent since April 2024, from £11.44 to £12.71, and rises again to £13.21 from April 2027. Employer NI adds to that pressure. It went to 15 percent in April 2025 with its threshold cut to £5,000, and the Autumn Budget on 28 October 2026 left both unchanged, despite calls from retail and hospitality groups to raise the threshold. Pay and employment tax have risen together, and the effect is sharpest on the entry-level roles that retail and hospitality rely on. Business groups argue this has made it harder to take on young workers, at a point when vacancies are falling and unemployment is expected to rise.
This article sets out what is being proposed, how it would sit alongside the NI reliefs that already exist for younger workers, and what the change could be worth per employee in that age band.
What does the review propose?
The headline National Insurance measure is to double the threshold at which employers start paying, from £5,000 to £10,000 of earnings, for workers aged 21 to 24. The review proposes phasing this in over five years, beginning with retail and hospitality, and only when fiscal conditions allow.
This is a recommendation, not a decision. The Government has welcomed the review but has not committed to the National Insurance change, and it is expected to respond in the coming weeks.
The recommendation answers a long campaign from business groups and large employers. UK Hospitality has welcomed the proposed threshold rise as an immediate boost for job creation, estimating that around 240,000 hospitality jobs would benefit and that the sector would save about £170 million a year. Leaders of several large retail and hospitality chains have also urged the Chancellor to act. The shared argument is that rising employment costs have priced younger workers out of the sectors that have always offered the first rung of the career ladder.
The relief that already exists for younger workers
Employer NI relief for young people is not new: employers already pay no NI on two groups of younger staff, up to a generous earnings ceiling.
- Employees under 21 (NI category M): 0 percent employer NI on earnings up to the Upper Secondary Threshold of £50,270 a year. Above that level, the standard 15 percent applies.
- Apprentices under 25 (NI category H): the same 0 percent employer NI up to £50,270.
However, Milburn’s proposal does not give 21 to 24 year olds the same deal as under-21s. The existing reliefs are full exemptions up to £50,270, whereas the proposed measure is much smaller. It would lift the point at which employer NI starts from £5,000 to £10,000, so only the first £10,000 of a 21 to 24 year old’s pay would be free of employer NI, rather than the first £50,270. It narrows the cost gap that opens on an employee’s 21st birthday, but does not completely shut it.
Administratively, a threshold that depends on both age and sector is more complex than today’s reliefs. Employers would need a reliable way to flag eligible workers, and the Government would need to define which businesses count as retail or hospitality.
What does a 21 to 24 year old employee currently cost a business?
Take a 22 year old earning £24,000 a year, in a retail or hospitality role. The figures below are illustrative and assume the threshold doubles from £5,000 to £10,000 for this age group, as the review proposes.
| Current position | If the threshold doubles to £10,000 | |
| Salary | £24,000 | £24,000 |
| Earnings on which employer NI is due | £19,000 | £14,000 |
| Employer NI rate | 15 percent | 15 percent |
| Employer NI cost | £2,850 a year | £2,100 a year |
The saving in this example is £750 a year for each worker in that age band. Doubling the threshold removes employer NI on £5,000 of pay, which at 15 percent is £750. Across ten staff aged 21 to 24, this is about £7,500 a year. The saving is capped at £750 because only the slice of pay between £5,000 and £10,000 becomes exempt; unlike a full exemption, it does not grow with salary.
When compared with the rising wage bill, the relief looks more modest. The National Living Wage rises again in April 2027, adding about £975 a year in pay for a full-time worker aged 21 or over on a 37.5-hour week, or around £1,120 once employer NI is added. On that basis, the £750 saving would not cover even one year of the wage increase for the same worker. The measure helps with the cost of employment, but it does not reverse the direction of travel.
These numbers are worked on current rates and a provisional reading of the proposal.
What it could mean for retail and hospitality
These are labour-intensive sectors with a young workforce, so a change of this kind would land harder here than almost anywhere else. Retail and hospitality carry high numbers of staff in their early twenties, often on or near the National Living Wage, exactly the group the proposal targets.
For a business owner, the appeal is direct. Lower employer NI on 21 to 24 year olds would free up cash that could support hiring, hours or margin. It would also narrow the current cliff edge, where an employee’s cost to the business jumps on their 21st birthday.
The caution is equally direct. The review ties the National Insurance change to fiscal conditions allowing it, and the Government has not committed to it. A five-year phase-in means any benefit would arrive slowly, if at all.
What employers should do now
There is no action to take on the proposed relief itself yet, but there is sensible groundwork.
- Check your payroll categories. Confirm that every employee under 21, and every apprentice under 25, is in the correct zero-rate NI category. Missing this is a cost you are carrying today, before any new relief.
- Model your exposure. Work out how many staff sit in the 21 to 24 band and what a relief would be worth to the business, so you can act quickly if it is confirmed.
- Plan on current rates. Keep hiring and budgeting decisions based on the 15 percent rate that applies now, and treat any saving as upside rather than a certainty.
- Watch for the Government’s response, which is expected in the coming weeks, and for any detail in future fiscal events. That response will show whether the measure is adopted and when it would start.
Talk to us
If you want to understand what the current NI rules cost your business, or model what the proposed threshold change could be worth for your team, the Price Bailey Retail & Hospitality team can help.
We always recommend that you seek advice from a suitably qualified adviser before taking any action. The information on this page is intended as a general guide only. While we work to keep our content accurate and up to date, we cannot guarantee that it reflects the position at the time you are reading it. No responsibility for loss occasioned by any person acting or refraining from action as a result of this material can be accepted by the authors or the firm. For more information on our editorial process, click here.
Sign up to receive exclusive business insights
Join our community of industry leaders and receive exclusive reports, early event access, and expert advice to stay ahead – all delivered straight to your inbox.