Corporate criminal offences: is your charity taking the right precautions?
Corporate criminal liability has widened since these rules first arrived, and charities are not exempt. Two failures to prevent offences now sit on the statute book; HMRC has begun prosecuting, and larger charities in particular need to check that their procedures are fit for purpose.
This article explains both offences, which charities fall in scope, and the steps trustees should take.
Two offences charities need to know about
Both offences work in the same way. An organisation is criminally liable if a person associated with it criminally facilitates a crime, and the organisation fails to prevent it. The organisation does not need to have known; the only defence is having reasonable procedures in place.
1. Failure to prevent the facilitation of tax evasion
Introduced by the Criminal Finances Act 2017 and in force from 30 September 2017, this offence applies to all organisations, incorporated charities included, regardless of size. An associated person can be an employee, a volunteer, an agent or anyone who performs services for or on behalf of the charity. Fines are unlimited.
2. Failure to prevent fraud
This is the newer offence, introduced by the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 and in force from 1 September 2025. It makes large organisations liable where an associated person commits a specified fraud intended to benefit the organisation, and the organisation failed to prevent it. It also carries unlimited fines.
Which charities are in scope
The two offences have different reach, and that difference shapes how your charity should respond.
The tax evasion offence applies to every charity, whatever its size. The fraud offence applies only to large organisations, defined as those meeting at least two of three criteria: more than 250 employees, more than £36m turnover, or more than £18m in total assets. Larger charities that meet the threshold are therefore in scope of both offences. Smaller charities remain in scope of the tax evasion offence but fall outside the fraud offence.
Even where the fraud offence does not apply, the Government guidance reflects good practice on fraud prevention that charities of any size may choose to adopt.
Enforcement is no longer theoretical
When these rules first appeared, enforcement was a prospect rather than a reality. That has changed. HMRC has secured its first charging decision under the tax evasion offence, and the first prosecution has reached court. HMRC also publishes its caseload twice a year, and its most recent figures reported 13 live investigations with a further 27 opportunities under review. The direction of travel is clear, and trustees should assume scrutiny will increase rather than ease.
The defence: reasonable procedures
For both offences the defence is the same: that the charity had reasonable procedures in place to prevent the facilitation, or that it was not reasonable to expect any. Guidance for both offences is built on six principles:
- Risk assessment: understand where the charity is exposed.
- Proportionate, risk-based procedures: match the response to the level of risk.
- Top-level commitment: trustees and senior management set the tone.
- Due diligence: know your people, partners and agents.
- Communication and training: make sure staff and volunteers understand their responsibilities.
- Monitoring and review: keep procedures current as the charity changes.
Procedures put in place for one offence will not automatically count as reasonable for the other, but they are a sound starting point.
What your charity should do now
Practical steps for trustees and finance leaders:
- Confirm which offences apply to your charity, based on its size and structure.
- Carry out or refresh a risk assessment for tax evasion facilitation and, where in scope, for fraud.
- Review and document your existing controls, and add staff and volunteer training where there are gaps.
- Record the judgements you make, so you can evidence reasonable procedures if you are ever challenged.
Documentation is central. If procedures are not written down, they are hard to rely on as a defence.
How Price Bailey can help
The Price Bailey Charity & NFP team works with trustees to assess exposure to both corporate criminal offences and to put proportionate, well-documented procedures in place. If you would like to review where your charity stands, get in touch.
We always recommend that you seek advice from a suitably qualified adviser before taking any action. The information on this page is intended as a general guide only. While we work to keep our content accurate and up to date, we cannot guarantee that it reflects the position at the time you are reading it. No responsibility for loss occasioned by any person acting or refraining from action as a result of this material can be accepted by the authors or the firm. For more information on our editorial process, click here.
Sign up to receive exclusive business insights
Join our community of industry leaders and receive exclusive reports, early event access, and expert advice to stay ahead – all delivered straight to your inbox.
Would you like to review where your charity stands? Contact us here...
We can help
Contact us today to find out more about how we can help you